Reading Response~It’s Monday!!

Monster by Walter Dean Myers

Monster Graphic Novel Adapted by Guy A. Sims & Illustrated by Dawud Anyabwile

This past week, I decided to read two different versions of the same novel, Monster by Walter Dean Myers. My reasoning behind reading the novel and then the graphic novel was twofold; first I wanted to read the novel itself and secondly, I had never read a graphic novel so I wanted to see what the differences were.

Monster is a novel that follows the trial of a sixteen year old African American boy named Steve Harmon. Steve is accused of helping to rob a drug store and in the midst of the robbery, the owner is shot and killed. The story is told by Steve Harmon, who writes about his trial as a movie screenplay. On trial are two of the four accused robbers; Steve and James King. The other two accomplices Richard “Bobo” Evans and Osvaldo Cruz, have entered plea deals in exchange for their testimony. Throughout the story, Steve flashes back to times in his school’s film club and the discussions he had with his teacher. The majority of the book follows the trial and we find that the title “Monster” is derived from the prosecutor Sandra Petrocelli, who describes the accused as “monsters”. Steve maintains his innocence throughout the trial telling the jury that he hardly knows the others involved. In the end, we find that James King is found guilty and Steve is found innocent. But even though he is found innocent, when he goes to hug his lawyer, Kathy O’Brien, she pulls away. This brings to question if Miss O’Brien ever saw Steve as himself or if she also saw him only as a “monster”.

I really enjoyed the novel and especially the format in which it was written. It was an extremely quick read as a movie screenplay, and it allowed you to really visualize everything as it was happening. I think this book would be an excellent book for anyone to read but especially youths who may be headed down a wrong direction. It shows how choices can affect your life and the consequences of those choices. It also is very revealing that even though you may not be guilty, people’s perception of you can change from even being accused; as Steve found out from his dad, who basically was never able to see Steve as the same boy he was before the incident.

The graphic novel was very well done and I enjoyed the illustrations. I can not say that I enjoyed the graphic novel as much as the regular novel though. This is completely a personal preference. I have never been much of a “comic” reader and to me, that’s what the graphic novel felt like. I can see where students that have a hard time reading a novel would enjoy the graphic novel version, but it just wasn’t for me. I think that if I had not read the regular book first, I would have been completely lost as to what was going on. I do plan on reading one more graphic novel, just to see if my perception changes; maybe if I don’t read the regular story first, I might enjoy a graphic novel. We will wait and see!

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Reading Response~It’s Monday!!

  1. Ooh! Now I have to make a graphic novel recommendation. (Or 20. I LOVE graphic novels!) What about Page by Paige by Laura Lee Gulledge? Or Roller Girl by Victoria Jamieson? Or Sunny Side Up by Jennifer Holm? Or El Deafo by Cece Bell? Or maybe all of those, LOL. Hopefully we can make a convert of you yet! (I’ve been curious about the graphic novel adaptation of Monster and love your project of reading both the novel and the adaptation at the same time to compare!)

    Like

    1. Thank you so much for the graphic novel recommendations! I haven’t completely ruled them out, in fact I ordered one from Amazon a couple of days ago! I will definitely check out your recommendations and keep an open mind before I give up!

      Like

Leave a Reply to Holly Nolte Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s